However, the issues of mother's diet vs. breast milk composition, and essential fatty acid (EFA) composition of milk, have been researched extensively, so that reasonable inferences about fruitarian breast milk can be made.

A baby nursing at a mother's breast is an undeniable affirmation of our rootedness in nature. Many fruitarian women do not menstruate--a symptom reported in anorexia nervosa and starvation.

Lipids, Jan. 1996, 31(1):115-9. Hornstra G, Al MD, van Houwelingen AC, Foreman-van Drongelen MM (1995) "Essential fatty acids in pregnancy and early human development." The above establishes that the fruit = milk theory is potentially dangerous to innocent children.

), Thus we see that the milk composition data used by the fruit = milk theory proponents (and those promoting crank-science "protein is toxic" theories) don't even necessarily extend to the end of the weaning period! Revista de Investigacion Clinica, Nov.-Dec. 1996, 48(6):473-8. NLM 1996, 31 Suppl:S279-82. Motil et al.
Compiling the data here--doing the analysis, and writing it up--has required a considerable effort. [No authors listed] PIP: Recent evidence on the beneficial effects of breast feeding were reported in the Proceedings of the American National Academy of Sciences. Obviously, reality contradicts the idea that milk composition during the milk-dependent period (A) is ideal for later life, or that the low protein content of milk in that period implies that adults really need very little protein. In fruitarian circles, an alleged "proof" has been circulated in the past that claims to statistically prove that the nutritional profile for milk is closer to that of fruit than any other food. Meanwhile, the real experience of those with anorexia nervosa (and some fruitarians) is that you starve when your caloric intake is too low. What if such a person were to substitute fruit/fruit juice for mother's milk (or for animal milk or formula) in the diet of an infant? (Defects of an Alleged Statistical "Proof" that Fruit and Mother's Milk are Similar) 1996, 31 Suppl:S279-82.

Now, the reason for elaborating the above is to clarify the (incorrect) logic of the fruit = milk promoters. Human milk is not just a food; it also complements the immaturity of organs in infants. Pretend that "fruit = milk" as some fruitarians claim.

What does their attempted evasion of responsibility say about their accountability? Neville MC, Allen JC, Archer PC, Casey CE, Seacat J, Keller RP, Lutes V, Rasbach J, Neifert M (1991) "Studies in human lactation: milk volume and composition during weaning and lactogenesis." (Or for the mathematically inclined, when ersatz statistical proofs may be offered--such as the "obligate crank science proof" mentioned above--compare the sloppy, mangled, and misinformed masquerade of such pseudo-statistics with the carefully considered foundation underlying the statistical approach and analysis taken here, as outlined in the appendix.)

To one, labeled S, add 1 gram sugar (any kind of pure sugar).

Motil KJ, Sheng HP, Montandon CM (1994) "Case report: failure to thrive in a breast-fed infant is associated with maternal dietary protein and energy restriction." They do say breastfeeding is nature's lipo. Ortiz-Olaya N, Flores ME, DeSantiago S (1996) "Significance of lipid consumption during lactation." Further, consider the fruitarians who promote the theory but then blithely claim, when confronted, that it should not be taken seriously. Revista de Investigacion Clinica, Nov.-Dec. 1996, 48(6):473-8. Makrides et al. Hence the fat requirements for lactation of fruitarian mothers must be met primarily by dietary intake of fat. Hardy SC, Kleinman RE (1994) "Fat and cholesterol in the diet of infants and young children: implications for growth, development, and long-term health." References for Section III USA.gov. However, I have never seen a fruitarian do this (up to the time this is written). Dilute solutions and They may say that the theory, and the criticisms thereof, are "just words" and nothing to be excited about. Reddy et al. This site needs JavaScript to work properly. Hornstra et al. Then reflect on how likely it is that there is any serious evidence or legitimate scientific research to back up the fruitarian claims, in contrast to bogus analogies based on oversimplified data and/or the emotional appeal of superficial slogans. Neville MC, Allen JC, Archer PC, Casey CE, Seacat J, Keller RP, Lutes V, Rasbach J, Neifert M (1991) "Studies in human lactation: milk volume and composition during weaning and lactogenesis." But then they turn right around and assume just the opposite where humans are concerned. That way if the numbers look like they will point to an inconvenient conclusion, you can ignore them and find another way to crank out some numbers that suit you better. report that DHA supplementation increased DHA levels in breast milk (vs. control group). Birch E, Birch D, Hoffman D, Hale L, Everett M, Uauy R (1993) "Breast-feeding and optimal visual development." European Journal of Clinical Nutrition, May 1994, 48(5):358-68. Perhaps they don't mention it because it puts them in the uncomfortable position of admitting that fruit is really not like milk? report that even trans-fatty acids (partially hydrogenated, "artificial" fats) find their way into breast milk! Nettleton JA (1993) "Are n-3 fatty acids essential nutrients for fetal and infant development?"

Indeed, a rigorous examination of the alleged "proof" shows that it analyzes the wrong data (hard to believe, but true), uses inappropriate analytical methods (covariance, correlation) for the data to be considered, plus uses the methods incorrectly, and even manages to derive invalid conclusions from the numbers that were produced by the incorrect proof. Makrides et al. Pediatric Research, Sept. 1995, 38(3):361-5. Another example will illustrate this further. Makrides M, Neumann MA, Simmer K, Gibson RA (1995) "Erythrocyte fatty acids of term infants fed either breast milk, standard formula, or formula supplemented with long-chain polyunsaturates."

European Journal of Obstetrics, Gynecology, and Reproductive Biology, July 1995, 61(1):57-62. Back to beginning of article report that the hepatic (liver) enzymes needed for the final stage conversion of LNA to DHA might be inactive during the first few months of an infant's life. Similar logic suggests that fruitarian babies probably have lower DHA levels as well. Additionally, readers may note the significant effort required to debunk bogus claims that many fruitarians make in a casual manner.

science "proof" GO TO FINAL SECTION OF ARTICLE (The fact that a few mothers and babies may thrive on such a diet is not proof.

This is made even easier when one doesn't have the necessary training in statistical methods to recognize the nature of the issues involved in what they are attempting in the first place.) Back to Research-Based Appraisals of Alternative Diet Lore Out of common decency and common sense, fruitarians who promote the phony fruit = milk theory should make a point of consistently, clearly, and explicitly stating that fruit cannot be substituted for milk in the diet of young infants.
The Universe Of Numbers Pdf, Truancy Synonym, Bondi Rescue Season 11 Episode 2, The House At The End Of The Street Trailer, Nc State Basketball 2020-21 Roster, Brampton Canada University, Is Wonky Donkey Offensive, Everlast What It's Like Album, Airbnb Portimão Praia Da Rocha, Knock Me Down Lyrics Meaning, Lychee Dessert Chinese, Illinois State Covid Procurement, Mount Ecclesia, Turn Of The Screw Shmoop, Supplier Clearinghouse Dbe, Scalar Chain, Ncaa March Madness 2003 Video Game, William Cullen Bryant Awards, International Bar Association Log In, Giada In Italy Season 5, Innovation Strategy Pdf, City Of Atlanta Procurement, University Of Munich Master's, 677 Park Road North Brantford, Jd Advising Login, Sec Championship 2018, Kathleen Klinghoffer, Durham Obituaries, What Does Shawty Mean In Rap, Under Heavy Fire, Spur Conversation, How Much Is Ella Egg Stikeez Worth, " />


The mother's body is very efficient in using dietary fat sources for breast milk production. As one of the other writers on this site mentioned in a post on the "Raw" email list (from memory, paraphrased): "Calories are not a theory. She did not know until years later that the the first child--the healthy one--was regularly given cow's milk to drink by the babysitters.) Back to Research-Based Appraisals of Alternative Diet Lore Birch E, Birch D, Hoffman D, Hale L, Everett M, Uauy R (1993) "Breast-feeding and optimal visual development."
However, the issues of mother's diet vs. breast milk composition, and essential fatty acid (EFA) composition of milk, have been researched extensively, so that reasonable inferences about fruitarian breast milk can be made.

A baby nursing at a mother's breast is an undeniable affirmation of our rootedness in nature. Many fruitarian women do not menstruate--a symptom reported in anorexia nervosa and starvation.

Lipids, Jan. 1996, 31(1):115-9. Hornstra G, Al MD, van Houwelingen AC, Foreman-van Drongelen MM (1995) "Essential fatty acids in pregnancy and early human development." The above establishes that the fruit = milk theory is potentially dangerous to innocent children.

), Thus we see that the milk composition data used by the fruit = milk theory proponents (and those promoting crank-science "protein is toxic" theories) don't even necessarily extend to the end of the weaning period! Revista de Investigacion Clinica, Nov.-Dec. 1996, 48(6):473-8. NLM 1996, 31 Suppl:S279-82. Motil et al.
Compiling the data here--doing the analysis, and writing it up--has required a considerable effort. [No authors listed] PIP: Recent evidence on the beneficial effects of breast feeding were reported in the Proceedings of the American National Academy of Sciences. Obviously, reality contradicts the idea that milk composition during the milk-dependent period (A) is ideal for later life, or that the low protein content of milk in that period implies that adults really need very little protein. In fruitarian circles, an alleged "proof" has been circulated in the past that claims to statistically prove that the nutritional profile for milk is closer to that of fruit than any other food. Meanwhile, the real experience of those with anorexia nervosa (and some fruitarians) is that you starve when your caloric intake is too low. What if such a person were to substitute fruit/fruit juice for mother's milk (or for animal milk or formula) in the diet of an infant? (Defects of an Alleged Statistical "Proof" that Fruit and Mother's Milk are Similar) 1996, 31 Suppl:S279-82.

Now, the reason for elaborating the above is to clarify the (incorrect) logic of the fruit = milk promoters. Human milk is not just a food; it also complements the immaturity of organs in infants. Pretend that "fruit = milk" as some fruitarians claim.

What does their attempted evasion of responsibility say about their accountability? Neville MC, Allen JC, Archer PC, Casey CE, Seacat J, Keller RP, Lutes V, Rasbach J, Neifert M (1991) "Studies in human lactation: milk volume and composition during weaning and lactogenesis." (Or for the mathematically inclined, when ersatz statistical proofs may be offered--such as the "obligate crank science proof" mentioned above--compare the sloppy, mangled, and misinformed masquerade of such pseudo-statistics with the carefully considered foundation underlying the statistical approach and analysis taken here, as outlined in the appendix.)

To one, labeled S, add 1 gram sugar (any kind of pure sugar).

Motil KJ, Sheng HP, Montandon CM (1994) "Case report: failure to thrive in a breast-fed infant is associated with maternal dietary protein and energy restriction." They do say breastfeeding is nature's lipo. Ortiz-Olaya N, Flores ME, DeSantiago S (1996) "Significance of lipid consumption during lactation." Further, consider the fruitarians who promote the theory but then blithely claim, when confronted, that it should not be taken seriously. Revista de Investigacion Clinica, Nov.-Dec. 1996, 48(6):473-8. Makrides et al. Hence the fat requirements for lactation of fruitarian mothers must be met primarily by dietary intake of fat. Hardy SC, Kleinman RE (1994) "Fat and cholesterol in the diet of infants and young children: implications for growth, development, and long-term health." References for Section III USA.gov. However, I have never seen a fruitarian do this (up to the time this is written). Dilute solutions and They may say that the theory, and the criticisms thereof, are "just words" and nothing to be excited about. Reddy et al. This site needs JavaScript to work properly. Hornstra et al. Then reflect on how likely it is that there is any serious evidence or legitimate scientific research to back up the fruitarian claims, in contrast to bogus analogies based on oversimplified data and/or the emotional appeal of superficial slogans. Neville MC, Allen JC, Archer PC, Casey CE, Seacat J, Keller RP, Lutes V, Rasbach J, Neifert M (1991) "Studies in human lactation: milk volume and composition during weaning and lactogenesis." But then they turn right around and assume just the opposite where humans are concerned. That way if the numbers look like they will point to an inconvenient conclusion, you can ignore them and find another way to crank out some numbers that suit you better. report that DHA supplementation increased DHA levels in breast milk (vs. control group). Birch E, Birch D, Hoffman D, Hale L, Everett M, Uauy R (1993) "Breast-feeding and optimal visual development." European Journal of Clinical Nutrition, May 1994, 48(5):358-68. Perhaps they don't mention it because it puts them in the uncomfortable position of admitting that fruit is really not like milk? report that even trans-fatty acids (partially hydrogenated, "artificial" fats) find their way into breast milk! Nettleton JA (1993) "Are n-3 fatty acids essential nutrients for fetal and infant development?"

Indeed, a rigorous examination of the alleged "proof" shows that it analyzes the wrong data (hard to believe, but true), uses inappropriate analytical methods (covariance, correlation) for the data to be considered, plus uses the methods incorrectly, and even manages to derive invalid conclusions from the numbers that were produced by the incorrect proof. Makrides et al. Pediatric Research, Sept. 1995, 38(3):361-5. Another example will illustrate this further. Makrides M, Neumann MA, Simmer K, Gibson RA (1995) "Erythrocyte fatty acids of term infants fed either breast milk, standard formula, or formula supplemented with long-chain polyunsaturates."

European Journal of Obstetrics, Gynecology, and Reproductive Biology, July 1995, 61(1):57-62. Back to beginning of article report that the hepatic (liver) enzymes needed for the final stage conversion of LNA to DHA might be inactive during the first few months of an infant's life. Similar logic suggests that fruitarian babies probably have lower DHA levels as well. Additionally, readers may note the significant effort required to debunk bogus claims that many fruitarians make in a casual manner.

science "proof" GO TO FINAL SECTION OF ARTICLE (The fact that a few mothers and babies may thrive on such a diet is not proof.

This is made even easier when one doesn't have the necessary training in statistical methods to recognize the nature of the issues involved in what they are attempting in the first place.) Back to Research-Based Appraisals of Alternative Diet Lore Out of common decency and common sense, fruitarians who promote the phony fruit = milk theory should make a point of consistently, clearly, and explicitly stating that fruit cannot be substituted for milk in the diet of young infants.

The Universe Of Numbers Pdf, Truancy Synonym, Bondi Rescue Season 11 Episode 2, The House At The End Of The Street Trailer, Nc State Basketball 2020-21 Roster, Brampton Canada University, Is Wonky Donkey Offensive, Everlast What It's Like Album, Airbnb Portimão Praia Da Rocha, Knock Me Down Lyrics Meaning, Lychee Dessert Chinese, Illinois State Covid Procurement, Mount Ecclesia, Turn Of The Screw Shmoop, Supplier Clearinghouse Dbe, Scalar Chain, Ncaa March Madness 2003 Video Game, William Cullen Bryant Awards, International Bar Association Log In, Giada In Italy Season 5, Innovation Strategy Pdf, City Of Atlanta Procurement, University Of Munich Master's, 677 Park Road North Brantford, Jd Advising Login, Sec Championship 2018, Kathleen Klinghoffer, Durham Obituaries, What Does Shawty Mean In Rap, Under Heavy Fire, Spur Conversation, How Much Is Ella Egg Stikeez Worth,